Today I found out that one of my publications, a peer-reviewed conference paper which is available free online, was published without my consent on a journal that I’ve never submitted to. What makes matters worse is that the journal is charging $48 for access for a paper that is freely available on the original conference website! The university that I’m affiliated with doesn’t have a subscription to this journal so I can’t check what the published piece looks like. I can’t check if my work has been edited in any way.
I’ve written to the original editor of the conference proceedings to clarify things, but it got me thinking about how confusing academic publications have increasingly become. It can be tough to sort out what’s happening to our content as previous papers are cross-published online. For junior scholars, it can be tricky to work out which journals have a reputable editorial board. So what can we do to protect our work?
Tips to protect our work
Here’s some general advice:
Use Google Scholar: This was how I realised that the journal had poached my content. It works by pulling web content. You can manually add references but can’t add links. You need to upload your papers to one of the services below for Google Scholar to be able to add a link to your work. Here’s some good tips on how to improve your Google Scholar profile.
Sign up with a copyright agency: Australia’s Copyright Agency offers a free service where they will help you fight copyright infringements. They have helped a friend of mine get royalties for books and teaching materials that republished my friend’s research without payment. Australians can get help here.
Join a Researcher Network: I belong to both ResearchGate and Academia.edu. I use the former very little, but most of my papers are up there. It is a free membership-based system to share papers and answer academic questions from other researchers.
Academia.edu is widely used, and I have my papers on there too (I joined that before ResearchGate). A few years a go there were concerns about their terms and conditions. I enjoy it as an alternative way to keep up with what researchers are publishing. Both services help your Google Scholar profile, and most importantly help you keep control of your public publishing profile.
Has something like this happened to you? Do you have other tips to help researchers protect their work?
I’ve become a pretty big fan of academia.edu; it’s been exposing me to a lot of interesting work that I wouldn’t have encountered otherwise. In lieu of a real humanities & social sciences arXiv it has become a pretty useful repository.
LikeLike
Thanks for the info, Zuleyka Zevallos! Up until now I’ve used Google scholar but not the other two services you mention. I will give them a try.
LikeLike
Thanks for the heads up. I hadn’t heard of this. I’ve heard of plenty of spam conferences. Please post again if you find out who is behind this.
LikeLike
Thanks Daniel Estrada Being able to follow people and topics on Academia.edu is extremely useful!
LikeLike
Jonah Miller Let me know how you go! The good thing about ResearchGate is that you can link to co-authors and then you keep up with what their networks are reading and posting about. It’s good for me as I keep up with researchers I haven’t worked with in years.
LikeLike
Thanks very much Letha McGarity! I’ll be sure to update.
LikeLike
Harry Tuttle Oh no. I’ve not heard of spam conferences! Do they physically happen or are they just money making scams? Thanks for your encouragement; I’ll post again with any tips once this is resolved.
LikeLike
It really sucks that someone would steal your work.
You might fire off DMCA notices to both the publisher and the journal. Interestingly, you can also send notices to the journal’s hosting service, who will pressure the journal to remove your content or be un-hosted, and search services like Google, who may block the offender from search indexing, effectively black-hole-ing them into internet obscurity.
Here is one guide (of many) to the DMCA process: http://www.whoishostingthis.com/blog/2013/05/02/dmca-notices-guide/
LikeLike
I will, Zuleyka Zevallos! Thanks! Research gate sound great.
LikeLike
Thanks for this suggestion Michael Verona I hadn’t thought of these options. I will definitely pursue it if I don’t get anywhere via the Copyright Agency. Much appreciated!
LikeLike
As someone who reads a ton of science journal articles, this is very disturbing.
I wish you the best figuring all this out.
LikeLike
Thanks very much Gary Ray R.
LikeLike
Zuleyka Zevallos spam conferences happen. They put up a list of invited speakers you know on a nice web site – normally they don’t ask the speaker or may have duped them into accepting an invitation. They usually combine a few wildly different themes. You turn up and there is nothing… A while ago some people were listing these publicly to help but haven’t seen many recently – perhaps they’ve moved on to other fields.
LikeLike
That is bizarre and awful Harry Tuttle! Thanks for telling me more. There’s clearly a whole strange world of academic racketeering.
LikeLike
Smsmssmsmsmßsmsmzm ßmsmsmsmssnsmsnwwnwnwwnwnwnwnwnwwemenenenenesnsnssnssnsnssnsnsnssnssnnnssnnssnsn
Smsmsmsmsmsamamamaamammamaamajaasjamssmsmakk
SMSs s s
LikeLike